GOV-16.1: Material Risks
Mechanisms exist to define criteria necessary to designate a risk as a material risk.
Control Question: Does the organization define criteria necessary to designate a risk as a material risk?
General (3)
| Framework | Mapping Values |
|---|---|
| ISO 42001 2023 | 6.1.2(c) 6.1.2(d) 6.1.2(d)(1) 6.1.2(d)(2) 6.1.2(d)(3) 6.1.2(e) 6.1.2(e)(1) 6.1.2(e)(2) |
| NAIC Insurance Data Security Model Law (MDL-668) | 4.E(2)(b) |
| SCF CORE Mergers, Acquisitions & Divestitures (MA&D) | GOV-16.1 |
US (2)
| Framework | Mapping Values |
|---|---|
| US SEC Cybersecurity Rule | 17 CFR 229.105(a) 17 CFR 229.105(b) 17 CFR 229.106(b)(2) |
| US - NY DFS 23 NYCRR500 2023 Amd 2 | 500.4(b) 500.4(b)(3) 500.4(b)(5) 500.9(b)(1) 500.9(b)(2) |
Capability Maturity Model
Level 0 — Not Performed
There is no evidence of a capability to define criteria necessary to designate a risk as a material risk.
Level 1 — Performed Informally
C|P-CMM1 is N/A, since a structured process is required to designate a risk as a material risk.
Level 2 — Planned & Tracked
C|P-CMM2 is N/A, since a well-defined process is required to designate a risk as a material risk.
Level 3 — Well Defined
Cybersecurity & Privacy Governance (GOV) efforts are standardized across the organization and centrally managed, where technically feasible, to ensure consistency. CMM Level 3 control maturity would reasonably expect all, or at least most, the following criteria to exist:
- Statutory, regulatory and contractual compliance requirements for cybersecurity and data privacy are identified and documented. Recurring testing is utilized to assess adherence to internal standards and/or external compliance requirements.
- A Governance, Risk & Compliance (GRC) function, or similar function, provides scoping guidance to determine control applicability.
- Internal policies and standards address all statutory, regulatory and contractual obligations for cybersecurity and data privacy.
- Controls are standardized across the organization to ensure uniformity and consistent execution.
- Corporate governance (executive oversight) exists for the cybersecurity and data privacy, which includes regular briefings to ensure executives have sufficient situational awareness to properly govern the organization.
- Procedures are established for sensitive/regulated compliance obligations that are standardized across the organization.
- Defined roles & responsibilities require data/process owners to define, implement and maintain cybersecurity and data protection controls for each system, application and/ or service of which they have accountability.
- The organization designates one or more qualified individuals to govern the cybersecurity and data privacy programs (e.g., Chief Information Security Officer or Chief Privacy Officer).
- Risk management processes are defined, to include materiality considerations.
Level 4 — Quantitatively Controlled
See C|P-CMM3. There are no defined C|P-CMM4 criteria, since it is reasonable to assume a quantitatively-controlled process is not necessary to designate a risk as a material risk.
Level 5 — Continuously Improving
See C|P-CMM4. There are no defined C|P-CMM5 criteria, since it is reasonable to assume a continuously-improving process is not necessary to designate a risk as a material risk.
Assessment Objectives
- GOV-16.1_A01 organization-specific criteria to designate a risk as a "material risk," as it pertains to materiality considerations, is documented.
Evidence Requirements
- E-GOV-15 Material Risks
-
Documented evidence of specific risks that are categorized as material risks.
Cybersecurity & Data Protection Management
Technology Recommendations
Micro/Small
- SCF Cybersecurity & Data Privacy Risk Management Model (C|P-RMM) (https://securecontrolsframework.com/risk-management-model)
Small
- SCF Cybersecurity & Data Privacy Risk Management Model (C|P-RMM) (https://securecontrolsframework.com/risk-management-model)
Medium
- SCF Cybersecurity & Data Privacy Risk Management Model (C|P-RMM) (https://securecontrolsframework.com/risk-management-model)
Large
- SCF Cybersecurity & Data Privacy Risk Management Model (C|P-RMM) (https://securecontrolsframework.com/risk-management-model)
Enterprise
- SCF Cybersecurity & Data Privacy Risk Management Model (C|P-RMM) (https://securecontrolsframework.com/risk-management-model)